ResourcesHiring

How Much Do Staffing Agencies Charge?

Direct-hire placement fees, temp and contract markups, temp-to-hire conversion fees and RPO pricing, with worked examples so you can compare quotes on the same basis.

By Michael Wood, Scylla Solutions7 min read

How much do staffing agencies charge? It depends on how you hire. A staffing agency is paid in one of three ways: a one-time fee when you hire someone permanently, a markup on every hour a temporary or contract worker works, or a program fee when the agency runs part of your recruiting for you. The ranges below are typical across the industry. Actual pricing varies with the role, the market and how scarce the skills are.

Direct-hire placement fees

When an agency finds you a permanent employee, you pay a one-time fee, usually a percentage of the hire’s first-year base salary. Fees commonly fall somewhere around 15% to 25%, and run higher for executive, specialised or hard-to-fill roles.

Worked example: a $90,000 role at a 20% fee costs $18,000, typically invoiced once the person starts. Most direct-hire work is contingent: you pay only if you hire someone the agency presented. Retained searches, used mainly for senior roles, are paid partly up front.

Direct-hire fee by salary

What the common 15% to 25% range means in dollars, calculated on first-year base salary:

First-year base salaryFee at 15%Fee at 20%Fee at 25%
$50,000$7,500$10,000$12,500
$75,000$11,250$15,000$18,750
$100,000$15,000$20,000$25,000
$150,000$22,500$30,000$37,500

Check whether the agreement calculates the fee on base salary only or on total first-year compensation including bonus: on a role with a large bonus, that changes the fee more than the percentage does.

Contingent vs retained direct-hire fees

A contingent fee is paid only if you hire a candidate the agency presented, usually invoiced on the start date. A retained search is paid in instalments, often a third up front, a third at shortlist and a third at hire, and is used mainly for senior and executive roles where the agency commits a dedicated search.

Ask about the guarantee period. If the hire leaves or is let go within an agreed window, many agencies replace them at no extra fee or refund part of the fee. The length and terms vary, so get them in writing.

Temp and contract markups

For temporary and contract workers, the agency employs the worker and bills you an hourly bill rate. The bill rate is the worker’s pay rate plus a markup. The markup is not all profit: it has to cover the employer’s payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, unemployment insurance, any benefits, payroll processing, recruiting cost and the agency’s margin.

Worked example: a worker paid $25 an hour at a 50% markup bills at $37.50 an hour. Markups vary widely by industry and skill level; light industrial work usually carries a lower markup than specialised IT or healthcare roles, where recruiting is harder and pay rates are higher.

When you compare quotes, compare bill rates for the same pay rate, and ask what the markup includes. A low markup that excludes overtime, benefits or workers’ comp is not cheaper.

Temp-to-hire conversion fees

Contract-to-hire lets you work with someone before hiring them permanently. If you hire them before an agreed number of hours or weeks, most agreements charge a conversion fee, often reduced the longer the worker has been with you and sometimes waived entirely after a set period. Check the conversion terms before the first day, not when you want to make the offer.

RPO pricing

In recruitment process outsourcing (RPO) the agency runs all or part of your recruiting function. Pricing is usually one of:

  • A monthly management fee for a dedicated recruiting team or capacity;
  • A fee per hire, usually well below a contingent placement fee because volume is committed;
  • A hybrid of a lower monthly fee plus a per-hire fee.

RPO tends to cost less per hire than contingent placements when you have steady, repeat hiring. For one or two hires a year, direct hire is usually simpler.

Which model fits your hire

  • One permanent role you need filled well: direct hire.
  • Seasonal peaks, projects or uncertain headcount: temp or contract.
  • You want to try before you commit: contract-to-hire.
  • Many hires a year, or recruiting is a bottleneck: RPO.

Questions to ask any agency before you sign

  • Is the fee calculated on base salary only, or on total compensation?
  • When is the fee invoiced, and on what payment terms?
  • What is the guarantee, and is it a replacement, a refund or both?
  • For temp and contract work, what exactly does the markup cover?
  • What are the conversion terms if we hire a contractor permanently?
  • Is the agreement exclusive, and for how long?

For the other side of the table, see how staffing agencies make money, which explains where the markup and the placement fee actually go. To see the hiring services Scylla Solutions offers, visit our solutions.

Frequently asked questions

How much do staffing agencies charge?

It depends on how you hire. Direct-hire placements usually cost a one-time fee of around 15% to 25% of the hire's first-year base salary. Temporary and contract workers are billed hourly at the worker's pay rate plus a mark-up. RPO is priced as a monthly management fee, a per-hire fee or a mix of both.

What is a typical staffing agency mark-up?

Mark-ups vary widely by industry and skill level; light industrial work usually carries a lower mark-up than specialised IT or healthcare roles. For example, a worker paid $25 an hour at a 50% mark-up bills at $37.50 an hour. The mark-up has to cover the agency's payroll taxes, workers' compensation, insurance, benefits and recruiting cost, not just its margin.

How much is a direct-hire placement fee?

Direct-hire fees commonly fall around 15% to 25% of the hire's first-year base salary, and run higher for executive, specialised or hard-to-fill roles. Most direct-hire work is contingent, so you pay only if you hire someone the agency presented, typically invoiced once the person starts.

Is a direct-hire fee based on base salary or total compensation?

Most agreements calculate the fee on first-year base salary, but some use total first-year compensation including bonus or commission. On a $100,000 base with a $20,000 bonus, a 20% fee is $20,000 on base salary and $24,000 on total compensation, so confirm the basis in writing before you sign.

What happens if a direct hire leaves soon after starting?

Most agencies offer a guarantee period. If the hire leaves or is let go within that window, many agencies replace them at no extra fee or refund part of the fee. The length and terms vary, so get the guarantee in writing before you sign.

Hiring in El Paso or nationally?

Get a quote for your role, not a rate card

Fees depend on the role, the market and how hard the search is. Tell Scylla Solutions what you are hiring for and we will tell you how we would price it, whether as a direct-hire placement, contract-to-hire or an RPO engagement.

Talk to Scylla Solutions